❝

❝ At a Birmingham law firm, the limitation date on an injury claim was held only in the calendar of an associate who then left. The three years ran out three days before her successor counted them. Modelled across 640 open matters, 72 need a look, 41 with no date at all. The design reads each file's documents, counts the period with fixed rules and asks the fee earner to confirm every date. It never sets one alone. About £30 a month to run.

The limitation date on Dean's claim was entered once, correctly, in Priya's Outlook calendar. Priya left the firm in June. Her calendar left with her.

Dean was knocked down by a reversing forklift at the distribution warehouse where he worked, on Monday 9 October 2023. He broke his ankle in two places and was off work for five months. He came to a dispute resolution and personal injury practice in Birmingham in March 2025, and Priya, an associate, took the case. She sent the letter of claim, the employer's insurer began its investigation, and she put the limitation date in her diary: Friday 9 October 2026.

She opened the matter on the case management system as a pre-action enquiry, the matter type the firm uses while it decides whether to take a case on. That type has no limitation field. When the case became a live claim a few weeks later, the type was changed and the new field was left blank. Nobody noticed, because the date was in Priya's diary, and Priya was looking after it.

Priya left on 30 June 2026. Her 70 open matters were split between two colleagues. Dean's went to Tom, with a handover note that said the insurer was still investigating and a medical report was awaited: the kind of file that drifts when nobody owns the date. On Monday 12 October 2026 Tom opened the file to chase the medical expert, read the accident date, and counted. The last day to bring the claim had been the previous Friday.

Liability was close to certain. The claim was worth, on the firm's own figures, about £38,000. That afternoon the firm told its indemnity insurer, and Tom began preparing to issue the claim anyway and ask the court to let it proceed.

The firm, Priya, Tom, Gareth and Dean are a composite, built from the patterns we see in litigation practices of this size, and the figures attached to them are design projections. The Limitation Act, the court rules and the cases are real, and linked to their sources.

Timeline: accident 9 October 2023, instructed March 2025, Priya leaves 30 June 2026, limitation ends 9 October 2026, file opened 12 October 2026

The business

A law firm in Birmingham with 46 staff. The dispute resolution and personal injury department has two partners, six fee earners and two trainees, and about 640 open matters: road traffic and workplace injury claims, contract and debt disputes, a handful of professional negligence claims against other advisers, and some property disputes.

Gareth, the supervising partner, runs a key-dates report from the case management system on the first Monday of every month and reads every date falling in the next 90 days. Each fee earner also keeps their own dates in Outlook. Most files are electronic. A few older ones still have a paper wallet with the limitation date written on the front.

What is actually going wrong

The firm has three limitation diaries, and none of them is the record.

The report cannot show a date that was never entered. Gareth's monthly report lists every key date in the system. Dean's matter had no key date, so it never appeared on the report. A blank field produces no line, and no line produces no question. The report was accurate about every matter it listed.

The period depends on the claim, and the claim is not always settled at file opening. Under the Limitation Act 1980, a claim in tort or in simple contract must be brought within six years of the date the cause of action accrued: for contract, the breach; for negligence, the damage. A claim on a deed has twelve years. A claim for personal injuries has three years from the date the cause of action accrued or, if later, the claimant's date of knowledge: broadly, when they knew the injury was significant, that it was caused by the act or omission complained of, and who was responsible. Negligence claims that are not about personal injury can run from a later date of knowledge under section 14A, subject to a fifteen-year longstop in section 14B. Fraud, deliberate concealment and mistake can postpone the start under section 32. A trainee typing a date into a field at file opening is, without anyone saying so, making a legal judgement about which of these applies.

Children and protected parties have a different start date. Under section 28, if the claimant was under a disability when the cause of action accrued, time runs from the date the disability ends. Under section 38 that includes being under 18, and lacking capacity to conduct proceedings within the meaning of the Mental Capacity Act 2005. For an injured child, the three years usually start on their eighteenth birthday. A person reaches an age at the start of the birthday (Family Law Reform Act 1969, section 9), so that day begins at midnight and counts, and the safe last day is the day before their twenty-first birthday. A date counted from the accident is the wrong date, even if it is a cautious one.

The counting has its own rules. The day the cause of action accrued is left out of the count, so for an accident on 9 October 2023 the three years ended at the end of 9 October 2026 (the rule from Marren v Dawson Bentley, restated by the Supreme Court in Matthew v Sedman). The same judgment made an exception for a cause of action that accrues at the very start of a day, at midnight, where that day does count. A paper claim is "brought" for limitation purposes on the date the court office receives it, which can be earlier than the issue date (paragraph 6.1 of Practice Direction 7A). Most represented damages claims in the County Court, Dean's included, must now go through the Damages Claims Portal, and there the claim is brought only when it is issued (Practice Direction 51ZB, paragraph 2.2), so plan to have it issued, not merely sent, by the last day. And bringing the claim is not the end of it: the claim form must then be served within four months under CPR 7.5, which is a second date the firm can miss.

The court's discretion is wide, uncertain and expensive. For personal injury claims only, section 33 lets the court allow a late claim to proceed if it would be equitable, weighing the prejudice to each side. It is a discretion, applied case by case. Tom's application on Dean's behalf has to explain the delay, and the explanation is that the date was in a calendar belonging to someone who had left. For a contract or a property claim there is no equivalent.

The regulator expects the firm to see this coming. The SRA Code of Conduct for Firms requires a firm to identify, monitor and manage all material risks to its business. A limitation date held in one person's diary is a material risk that the firm's own report cannot see.

What it costs

Run every one of the 640 open matters through a check of its documents against its recorded dates and, in this design, 72 of them need a look, about one in nine:

  • 41 matters with no limitation date in the case management system at all, most opened as enquiries or imported from the firm's old system.

  • 19 matters where the system and the fee earner's diary hold different dates.

  • 7 matters where the date was counted from the wrong starting point, usually the date the client first called or the date of the letter of claim, which puts it later than the real date.

  • 3 child claimants whose dates were counted from the accident. For a child, time runs from their eighteenth birthday.

  • 2 contract claims counted from the date the contract was signed. Time runs from the breach.

Ranked bars: of 640 open matters, 72 needed a look in this design: 41 no date recorded, 19 system and diary disagree, 7 counted from the wrong start, 3 child claimants, 2 contract claims from signing date

The last five are cautious errors: the recorded date is earlier than the real one. The first 48 (the 41 blanks and the 7 late counts) are the kind that end with a file like Dean's. The 19 disagreements are both, until somebody works out which date is right.

The cost of one missed date is easier to state than to add up. Dean's claim is worth about £38,000 in this design. If the section 33 application fails, Dean's remedy is a negligence claim against the firm for the claim he lost, which goes to the firm's indemnity insurer, carries the firm's excess, and appears on every renewal form for years afterwards. If it succeeds, the firm has paid for an application it should never have had to make, and the insurer still knows about it.

The time cost is steadier. Gareth spends about five hours on the first Monday of every month reading the key-dates report and emailing fee earners about the dates on it. That is five hours spent checking the dates that exist. None of it reaches the 41 that do not.

The design is next. It, the build guide, the running costs and the take-away are free to subscribers. Enter your email below and the rest of this Blueprint opens. New ones arrive every Tuesday and Friday.

Subscribe to keep reading

This content is free, but you must be subscribed to AdAI News to continue reading.

Already a subscriber?Sign in.Not now

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Keep Reading

View more